download

Hofheinz v. AMC Productions, 2001 (DECISION FOR USER)

AMC’s documentary It Conquered Hollywood! The Story of American International Pictures used material from I was a Teenage Frankenstein, I Was a Teenage Werewolf,The Amazing Colossal Man,The Invasion of the Saucerman,It Conquered the World, and Apache Women. The court found that the quotations were too few and too short to harm the market for the plaintiff’s works. It also noted that “the public would be hindered by a denial of defendants' fair use defense. Defendants have gone to considerable length to create a film that documents the origins of AIP and its significant impact on the American movie industry. It contains information which, if the general public does not find interesting, at the very least, movie aficionados across the country will find informative and entertaining.”

See more videos in "Fair Use and Documentaries in Court."

FOR USER. The court found that the quotations were too few and too short to harm the market for the plaintiff’s works. It also noted that “the public would be hindered by a denial of defendants' fair use defense. Defendants have gone to considerable length to create a film that documents the origins of AIP and its significant impact on the American movie industry. It contains information which, if the general public does not find interesting, at the very least, movie aficionados across the country will find informative and entertaining.”